github.com/xushiwei/go@v0.0.0-20130601165731-2b9d83f45bc9/src/cmd/cgo/doc.go (about) 1 // Copyright 2009 The Go Authors. All rights reserved. 2 // Use of this source code is governed by a BSD-style 3 // license that can be found in the LICENSE file. 4 5 /* 6 7 Cgo enables the creation of Go packages that call C code. 8 9 Usage: 10 go tool cgo [compiler options] file.go 11 12 The compiler options are passed through uninterpreted when 13 invoking gcc to compile the C parts of the package. 14 15 The input file.go is a syntactically valid Go source file that imports 16 the pseudo-package "C" and then refers to types such as C.size_t, 17 variables such as C.stdout, or functions such as C.putchar. 18 19 If the import of "C" is immediately preceded by a comment, that 20 comment, called the preamble, is used as a header when compiling 21 the C parts of the package. For example: 22 23 // #include <stdio.h> 24 // #include <errno.h> 25 import "C" 26 27 CFLAGS and LDFLAGS may be defined with pseudo #cgo directives 28 within these comments to tweak the behavior of gcc. Values defined 29 in multiple directives are concatenated together. Options prefixed 30 by $GOOS, $GOARCH, or $GOOS/$GOARCH are only defined in matching 31 systems. For example: 32 33 // #cgo CFLAGS: -DPNG_DEBUG=1 34 // #cgo linux CFLAGS: -DLINUX=1 35 // #cgo LDFLAGS: -lpng 36 // #include <png.h> 37 import "C" 38 39 Alternatively, CFLAGS and LDFLAGS may be obtained via the pkg-config 40 tool using a '#cgo pkg-config:' directive followed by the package names. 41 For example: 42 43 // #cgo pkg-config: png cairo 44 // #include <png.h> 45 import "C" 46 47 The CGO_CFLAGS and CGO_LDFLAGS environment variables are added 48 to the flags derived from these directives. Package-specific flags should 49 be set using the directives, not the environment variables, so that builds 50 work in unmodified environments. 51 52 Within the Go file, C identifiers or field names that are keywords in Go 53 can be accessed by prefixing them with an underscore: if x points at a C 54 struct with a field named "type", x._type accesses the field. 55 56 The standard C numeric types are available under the names 57 C.char, C.schar (signed char), C.uchar (unsigned char), 58 C.short, C.ushort (unsigned short), C.int, C.uint (unsigned int), 59 C.long, C.ulong (unsigned long), C.longlong (long long), 60 C.ulonglong (unsigned long long), C.float, C.double. 61 The C type void* is represented by Go's unsafe.Pointer. 62 63 To access a struct, union, or enum type directly, prefix it with 64 struct_, union_, or enum_, as in C.struct_stat. 65 66 Go structs cannot embed fields with C types. 67 68 Any C function (even void functions) may be called in a multiple 69 assignment context to retrieve both the return value (if any) and the 70 C errno variable as an error (use _ to skip the result value if the 71 function returns void). For example: 72 73 n, err := C.sqrt(-1) 74 _, err := C.voidFunc() 75 76 In C, a function argument written as a fixed size array 77 actually requires a pointer to the first element of the array. 78 C compilers are aware of this calling convention and adjust 79 the call accordingly, but Go cannot. In Go, you must pass 80 the pointer to the first element explicitly: C.f(&x[0]). 81 82 A few special functions convert between Go and C types 83 by making copies of the data. In pseudo-Go definitions: 84 85 // Go string to C string 86 // The C string is allocated in the C heap using malloc. 87 // It is the caller's responsibility to arrange for it to be 88 // freed, such as by calling C.free (be sure to include stdlib.h 89 // if C.free is needed). 90 func C.CString(string) *C.char 91 92 // C string to Go string 93 func C.GoString(*C.char) string 94 95 // C string, length to Go string 96 func C.GoStringN(*C.char, C.int) string 97 98 // C pointer, length to Go []byte 99 func C.GoBytes(unsafe.Pointer, C.int) []byte 100 101 Go functions can be exported for use by C code in the following way: 102 103 //export MyFunction 104 func MyFunction(arg1, arg2 int, arg3 string) int64 {...} 105 106 //export MyFunction2 107 func MyFunction2(arg1, arg2 int, arg3 string) (int64, *C.char) {...} 108 109 They will be available in the C code as: 110 111 extern int64 MyFunction(int arg1, int arg2, GoString arg3); 112 extern struct MyFunction2_return MyFunction2(int arg1, int arg2, GoString arg3); 113 114 found in _cgo_export.h generated header, after any preambles 115 copied from the cgo input files. Functions with multiple 116 return values are mapped to functions returning a struct. 117 Not all Go types can be mapped to C types in a useful way. 118 119 Using //export in a file places a restriction on the preamble: 120 since it is copied into two different C output files, it must not 121 contain any definitions, only declarations. Definitions must be 122 placed in preambles in other files, or in C source files. 123 124 Cgo transforms the input file into four output files: two Go source 125 files, a C file for 6c (or 8c or 5c), and a C file for gcc. 126 127 The standard package construction rules of the go command 128 automate the process of using cgo. See $GOROOT/misc/cgo/stdio 129 and $GOROOT/misc/cgo/gmp for examples. 130 131 Cgo does not yet work with gccgo. 132 133 See "C? Go? Cgo!" for an introduction to using cgo: 134 http://golang.org/doc/articles/c_go_cgo.html 135 */ 136 package main 137 138 /* 139 Implementation details. 140 141 Cgo provides a way for Go programs to call C code linked into the same 142 address space. This comment explains the operation of cgo. 143 144 Cgo reads a set of Go source files and looks for statements saying 145 import "C". If the import has a doc comment, that comment is 146 taken as literal C code to be used as a preamble to any C code 147 generated by cgo. A typical preamble #includes necessary definitions: 148 149 // #include <stdio.h> 150 import "C" 151 152 For more details about the usage of cgo, see the documentation 153 comment at the top of this file. 154 155 Understanding C 156 157 Cgo scans the Go source files that import "C" for uses of that 158 package, such as C.puts. It collects all such identifiers. The next 159 step is to determine each kind of name. In C.xxx the xxx might refer 160 to a type, a function, a constant, or a global variable. Cgo must 161 decide which. 162 163 The obvious thing for cgo to do is to process the preamble, expanding 164 #includes and processing the corresponding C code. That would require 165 a full C parser and type checker that was also aware of any extensions 166 known to the system compiler (for example, all the GNU C extensions) as 167 well as the system-specific header locations and system-specific 168 pre-#defined macros. This is certainly possible to do, but it is an 169 enormous amount of work. 170 171 Cgo takes a different approach. It determines the meaning of C 172 identifiers not by parsing C code but by feeding carefully constructed 173 programs into the system C compiler and interpreting the generated 174 error messages, debug information, and object files. In practice, 175 parsing these is significantly less work and more robust than parsing 176 C source. 177 178 Cgo first invokes gcc -E -dM on the preamble, in order to find out 179 about simple #defines for constants and the like. These are recorded 180 for later use. 181 182 Next, cgo needs to identify the kinds for each identifier. For the 183 identifiers C.foo and C.bar, cgo generates this C program: 184 185 <preamble> 186 void __cgo__f__(void) { 187 #line 1 "cgo-test" 188 foo; 189 enum { _cgo_enum_0 = foo }; 190 bar; 191 enum { _cgo_enum_1 = bar }; 192 } 193 194 This program will not compile, but cgo can look at the error messages 195 to infer the kind of each identifier. The line number given in the 196 error tells cgo which identifier is involved. 197 198 An error like "unexpected type name" or "useless type name in empty 199 declaration" or "declaration does not declare anything" tells cgo that 200 the identifier is a type. 201 202 An error like "statement with no effect" or "expression result unused" 203 tells cgo that the identifier is not a type, but not whether it is a 204 constant, function, or global variable. 205 206 An error like "not an integer constant" tells cgo that the identifier 207 is not a constant. If it is also not a type, it must be a function or 208 global variable. For now, those can be treated the same. 209 210 Next, cgo must learn the details of each type, variable, function, or 211 constant. It can do this by reading object files. If cgo has decided 212 that t1 is a type, v2 and v3 are variables or functions, and c4, c5, 213 and c6 are constants, it generates: 214 215 <preamble> 216 typeof(t1) *__cgo__1; 217 typeof(v2) *__cgo__2; 218 typeof(v3) *__cgo__3; 219 typeof(c4) *__cgo__4; 220 enum { __cgo_enum__4 = c4 }; 221 typeof(c5) *__cgo__5; 222 enum { __cgo_enum__5 = c5 }; 223 typeof(c6) *__cgo__6; 224 enum { __cgo_enum__6 = c6 }; 225 226 long long __cgo_debug_data[] = { 227 0, // t1 228 0, // v2 229 0, // v3 230 c4, 231 c5, 232 c6, 233 1 234 }; 235 236 and again invokes the system C compiler, to produce an object file 237 containing debug information. Cgo parses the DWARF debug information 238 for __cgo__N to learn the type of each identifier. (The types also 239 distinguish functions from global variables.) If using a standard gcc, 240 cgo can parse the DWARF debug information for the __cgo_enum__N to 241 learn the identifier's value. The LLVM-based gcc on OS X emits 242 incomplete DWARF information for enums; in that case cgo reads the 243 constant values from the __cgo_debug_data from the object file's data 244 segment. 245 246 At this point cgo knows the meaning of each C.xxx well enough to start 247 the translation process. 248 249 Translating Go 250 251 [The rest of this comment refers to 6g and 6c, the Go and C compilers 252 that are part of the amd64 port of the gc Go toolchain. Everything here 253 applies to another architecture's compilers as well.] 254 255 Given the input Go files x.go and y.go, cgo generates these source 256 files: 257 258 x.cgo1.go # for 6g 259 y.cgo1.go # for 6g 260 _cgo_gotypes.go # for 6g 261 _cgo_defun.c # for 6c 262 x.cgo2.c # for gcc 263 y.cgo2.c # for gcc 264 _cgo_export.c # for gcc 265 _cgo_main.c # for gcc 266 267 The file x.cgo1.go is a copy of x.go with the import "C" removed and 268 references to C.xxx replaced with names like _Cfunc_xxx or _Ctype_xxx. 269 The definitions of those identifiers, written as Go functions, types, 270 or variables, are provided in _cgo_gotypes.go. 271 272 Here is a _cgo_gotypes.go containing definitions for C.flush (provided 273 in the preamble) and C.puts (from stdio): 274 275 type _Ctype_char int8 276 type _Ctype_int int32 277 type _Ctype_void [0]byte 278 279 func _Cfunc_CString(string) *_Ctype_char 280 func _Cfunc_flush() _Ctype_void 281 func _Cfunc_puts(*_Ctype_char) _Ctype_int 282 283 For functions, cgo only writes an external declaration in the Go 284 output. The implementation is in a combination of C for 6c (meaning 285 any gc-toolchain compiler) and C for gcc. 286 287 The 6c file contains the definitions of the functions. They all have 288 similar bodies that invoke runtime·cgocall to make a switch from the 289 Go runtime world to the system C (GCC-based) world. 290 291 For example, here is the definition of _Cfunc_puts: 292 293 void _cgo_be59f0f25121_Cfunc_puts(void*); 294 295 void 296 ·_Cfunc_puts(struct{uint8 x[1];}p) 297 { 298 runtime·cgocall(_cgo_be59f0f25121_Cfunc_puts, &p); 299 } 300 301 The hexadecimal number is a hash of cgo's input, chosen to be 302 deterministic yet unlikely to collide with other uses. The actual 303 function _cgo_be59f0f25121_Cfunc_puts is implemented in a C source 304 file compiled by gcc, the file x.cgo2.c: 305 306 void 307 _cgo_be59f0f25121_Cfunc_puts(void *v) 308 { 309 struct { 310 char* p0; 311 int r; 312 char __pad12[4]; 313 } __attribute__((__packed__)) *a = v; 314 a->r = puts((void*)a->p0); 315 } 316 317 It extracts the arguments from the pointer to _Cfunc_puts's argument 318 frame, invokes the system C function (in this case, puts), stores the 319 result in the frame, and returns. 320 321 Linking 322 323 Once the _cgo_export.c and *.cgo2.c files have been compiled with gcc, 324 they need to be linked into the final binary, along with the libraries 325 they might depend on (in the case of puts, stdio). 6l has been 326 extended to understand basic ELF files, but it does not understand ELF 327 in the full complexity that modern C libraries embrace, so it cannot 328 in general generate direct references to the system libraries. 329 330 Instead, the build process generates an object file using dynamic 331 linkage to the desired libraries. The main function is provided by 332 _cgo_main.c: 333 334 int main() { return 0; } 335 void crosscall2(void(*fn)(void*, int), void *a, int c) { } 336 void _cgo_allocate(void *a, int c) { } 337 void _cgo_panic(void *a, int c) { } 338 339 The extra functions here are stubs to satisfy the references in the C 340 code generated for gcc. The build process links this stub, along with 341 _cgo_export.c and *.cgo2.c, into a dynamic executable and then lets 342 cgo examine the executable. Cgo records the list of shared library 343 references and resolved names and writes them into a new file 344 _cgo_import.c, which looks like: 345 346 #pragma cgo_dynamic_linker "/lib64/ld-linux-x86-64.so.2" 347 #pragma cgo_import_dynamic puts puts#GLIBC_2.2.5 "libc.so.6" 348 #pragma cgo_import_dynamic __libc_start_main __libc_start_main#GLIBC_2.2.5 "libc.so.6" 349 #pragma cgo_import_dynamic stdout stdout#GLIBC_2.2.5 "libc.so.6" 350 #pragma cgo_import_dynamic fflush fflush#GLIBC_2.2.5 "libc.so.6" 351 #pragma cgo_import_dynamic _ _ "libpthread.so.0" 352 #pragma cgo_import_dynamic _ _ "libc.so.6" 353 354 In the end, the compiled Go package, which will eventually be 355 presented to 6l as part of a larger program, contains: 356 357 _go_.6 # 6g-compiled object for _cgo_gotypes.go *.cgo1.go 358 _cgo_defun.6 # 6c-compiled object for _cgo_defun.c 359 _all.o # gcc-compiled object for _cgo_export.c, *.cgo2.c 360 _cgo_import.6 # 6c-compiled object for _cgo_import.c 361 362 The final program will be a dynamic executable, so that 6l can avoid 363 needing to process arbitrary .o files. It only needs to process the .o 364 files generated from C files that cgo writes, and those are much more 365 limited in the ELF or other features that they use. 366 367 In essence, the _cgo_import.6 file includes the extra linking 368 directives that 6l is not sophisticated enough to derive from _all.o 369 on its own. Similarly, the _all.o uses dynamic references to real 370 system object code because 6l is not sophisticated enough to process 371 the real code. 372 373 The main benefits of this system are that 6l remains relatively simple 374 (it does not need to implement a complete ELF and Mach-O linker) and 375 that gcc is not needed after the package is compiled. For example, 376 package net uses cgo for access to name resolution functions provided 377 by libc. Although gcc is needed to compile package net, gcc is not 378 needed to link programs that import package net. 379 380 Runtime 381 382 When using cgo, Go must not assume that it owns all details of the 383 process. In particular it needs to coordinate with C in the use of 384 threads and thread-local storage. The runtime package, in its own 385 (6c-compiled) C code, declares a few uninitialized (default bss) 386 variables: 387 388 bool runtime·iscgo; 389 void (*libcgo_thread_start)(void*); 390 void (*initcgo)(G*); 391 392 Any package using cgo imports "runtime/cgo", which provides 393 initializations for these variables. It sets iscgo to 1, initcgo to a 394 gcc-compiled function that can be called early during program startup, 395 and libcgo_thread_start to a gcc-compiled function that can be used to 396 create a new thread, in place of the runtime's usual direct system 397 calls. 398 399 [NOTE: From here down is planned but not yet implemented.] 400 401 Internal and External Linking 402 403 The text above describes "internal" linking, in which 6l parses and 404 links host object files (ELF, Mach-O, PE, and so on) into the final 405 executable itself. Keeping 6l simple means we cannot possibly 406 implement the full semantics of the host linker, so the kinds of 407 objects that can be linked directly into the binary is limited (other 408 code can only be used as a dynamic library). On the other hand, when 409 using internal linking, 6l can generate Go binaries by itself. 410 411 In order to allow linking arbitrary object files without requiring 412 dynamic libraries, cgo will soon support an "external" linking mode 413 too. In external linking mode, 6l does not process any host object 414 files. Instead, it collects all the Go code and writes a single go.o 415 object file containing it. Then it invokes the host linker (usually 416 gcc) to combine the go.o object file and any supporting non-Go code 417 into a final executable. External linking avoids the dynamic library 418 requirement but introduces a requirement that the host linker be 419 present to create such a binary. 420 421 Most builds both compile source code and invoke the linker to create a 422 binary. When cgo is involved, the compile step already requires gcc, so 423 it is not problematic for the link step to require gcc too. 424 425 An important exception is builds using a pre-compiled copy of the 426 standard library. In particular, package net uses cgo on most systems, 427 and we want to preserve the ability to compile pure Go code that 428 imports net without requiring gcc to be present at link time. (In this 429 case, the dynamic library requirement is less significant, because the 430 only library involved is libc.so, which can usually be assumed 431 present.) 432 433 This conflict between functionality and the gcc requirement means we 434 must support both internal and external linking, depending on the 435 circumstances: if net is the only cgo-using package, then internal 436 linking is probably fine, but if other packages are involved, so that there 437 are dependencies on libraries beyond libc, external linking is likely 438 to work better. The compilation of a package records the relevant 439 information to support both linking modes, leaving the decision 440 to be made when linking the final binary. 441 442 Linking Directives 443 444 In either linking mode, package-specific directives must be passed 445 through to 6l. These are communicated by writing #pragma directives 446 in a C source file compiled by 6c. The directives are copied into the .6 object file 447 and then processed by the linker. 448 449 The directives are: 450 451 #pragma cgo_import_dynamic <local> [<remote> ["<library>"]] 452 453 In internal linking mode, allow an unresolved reference to 454 <local>, assuming it will be resolved by a dynamic library 455 symbol. The optional <remote> specifies the symbol's name and 456 possibly version in the dynamic library, and the optional "<library>" 457 names the specific library where the symbol should be found. 458 459 In the <remote>, # or @ can be used to introduce a symbol version. 460 461 Examples: 462 #pragma cgo_import_dynamic puts 463 #pragma cgo_import_dynamic puts puts#GLIBC_2.2.5 464 #pragma cgo_import_dynamic puts puts#GLIBC_2.2.5 "libc.so.6" 465 466 A side effect of the cgo_import_dynamic directive with a 467 library is to make the final binary depend on that dynamic 468 library. To get the dependency without importing any specific 469 symbols, use _ for local and remote. 470 471 Example: 472 #pragma cgo_import_dynamic _ _ "libc.so.6" 473 474 For compatibility with current versions of SWIG, 475 #pragma dynimport is an alias for #pragma cgo_import_dynamic. 476 477 #pragma cgo_dynamic_linker "<path>" 478 479 In internal linking mode, use "<path>" as the dynamic linker 480 in the final binary. This directive is only needed from one 481 package when constructing a binary; by convention it is 482 supplied by runtime/cgo. 483 484 Example: 485 #pragma cgo_dynamic_linker "/lib/ld-linux.so.2" 486 487 #pragma cgo_export_dynamic <local> <remote> 488 489 In internal linking mode, put the Go symbol 490 named <local> into the program's exported symbol table as 491 <remote>, so that C code can refer to it by that name. This 492 mechanism makes it possible for C code to call back into Go or 493 to share Go's data. 494 495 For compatibility with current versions of SWIG, 496 #pragma dynexport is an alias for #pragma cgo_export_dynamic. 497 498 #pragma cgo_import_static <local> 499 500 In external linking mode, allow unresolved references to 501 <local> in the go.o object file prepared for the host linker, 502 under the assumption that <local> will be supplied by the 503 other object files that will be linked with go.o. 504 505 Example: 506 #pragma cgo_import_static puts_wrapper 507 508 #pragma cgo_export_static <local> <remote> 509 510 In external linking mode, put the Go symbol 511 named <local> into the program's exported symbol table as 512 <remote>, so that C code can refer to it by that name. This 513 mechanism makes it possible for C code to call back into Go or 514 to share Go's data. 515 516 #pragma cgo_ldflag "<arg>" 517 518 In external linking mode, invoke the host linker (usually gcc) 519 with "<arg>" as a command-line argument following the .o files. 520 Note that the arguments are for "gcc", not "ld". 521 522 Example: 523 #pragma cgo_ldflag "-lpthread" 524 #pragma cgo_ldflag "-L/usr/local/sqlite3/lib" 525 526 A package compiled with cgo will include directives for both 527 internal and external linking; the linker will select the appropriate 528 subset for the chosen linking mode. 529 530 Example 531 532 As a simple example, consider a package that uses cgo to call C.sin. 533 The following code will be generated by cgo: 534 535 // compiled by 6g 536 537 type _Ctype_double float64 538 func _Cfunc_sin(_Ctype_double) _Ctype_double 539 540 // compiled by 6c 541 542 #pragma cgo_import_dynamic sin sin#GLIBC_2.2.5 "libm.so.6" 543 544 #pragma cgo_import_static _cgo_gcc_Cfunc_sin 545 #pragma cgo_ldflag "-lm" 546 547 void _cgo_gcc_Cfunc_sin(void*); 548 549 void 550 ·_Cfunc_sin(struct{uint8 x[16];}p) 551 { 552 runtime·cgocall(_cgo_gcc_Cfunc_sin, &p); 553 } 554 555 // compiled by gcc, into foo.cgo2.o 556 557 void 558 _cgo_gcc_Cfunc_sin(void *v) 559 { 560 struct { 561 double p0; 562 double r; 563 } __attribute__((__packed__)) *a = v; 564 a->r = sin(a->p0); 565 } 566 567 What happens at link time depends on whether the final binary is linked 568 using the internal or external mode. If other packages are compiled in 569 "external only" mode, then the final link will be an external one. 570 Otherwise the link will be an internal one. 571 572 The directives in the 6c-compiled file are used according to the kind 573 of final link used. 574 575 In internal mode, 6l itself processes all the host object files, in 576 particular foo.cgo2.o. To do so, it uses the cgo_import_dynamic and 577 cgo_dynamic_linker directives to learn that the otherwise undefined 578 reference to sin in foo.cgo2.o should be rewritten to refer to the 579 symbol sin with version GLIBC_2.2.5 from the dynamic library 580 "libm.so.6", and the binary should request "/lib/ld-linux.so.2" as its 581 runtime dynamic linker. 582 583 In external mode, 6l does not process any host object files, in 584 particular foo.cgo2.o. It links together the 6g- and 6c-generated 585 object files, along with any other Go code, into a go.o file. While 586 doing that, 6l will discover that there is no definition for 587 _cgo_gcc_Cfunc_sin, referred to by the 6c-compiled source file. This 588 is okay, because 6l also processes the cgo_import_static directive and 589 knows that _cgo_gcc_Cfunc_sin is expected to be supplied by a host 590 object file, so 6l does not treat the missing symbol as an error when 591 creating go.o. Indeed, the definition for _cgo_gcc_Cfunc_sin will be 592 provided to the host linker by foo2.cgo.o, which in turn will need the 593 symbol 'sin'. 6l also processes the cgo_ldflag directives, so that it 594 knows that the eventual host link command must include the -lm 595 argument, so that the host linker will be able to find 'sin' in the 596 math library. 597 598 6l Command Line Interface 599 600 The go command and any other Go-aware build systems invoke 6l 601 to link a collection of packages into a single binary. By default, 6l will 602 present the same interface it does today: 603 604 6l main.a 605 606 produces a file named 6.out, even if 6l does so by invoking the host 607 linker in external linking mode. 608 609 By default, 6l will decide the linking mode as follows: if the only 610 packages using cgo are those on a whitelist of standard library 611 packages (net, os/user, runtime/cgo), 6l will use internal linking 612 mode. Otherwise, there are non-standard cgo packages involved, and 6l 613 will use external linking mode. The first rule means that a build of 614 the godoc binary, which uses net but no other cgo, can run without 615 needing gcc available. The second rule means that a build of a 616 cgo-wrapped library like sqlite3 can generate a standalone executable 617 instead of needing to refer to a dynamic library. The specific choice 618 can be overridden using a command line flag: 6l -cgolink=internal or 619 6l -cgolink=external. 620 621 In an external link, 6l will create a temporary directory, write any 622 host object files found in package archives to that directory (renamed 623 to avoid conflicts), write the go.o file to that directory, and invoke 624 the host linker. The default value for the host linker is $CC, split 625 into fields, or else "gcc". The specific host linker command line can 626 be overridden using a command line flag: 6l -hostld='gcc -ggdb' 627 628 These defaults mean that Go-aware build systems can ignore the linking 629 changes and keep running plain '6l' and get reasonable results, but 630 they can also control the linking details if desired. 631 632 */